Troll and Toad Reviews

Most of the time, they’ve got what I need, which is always nice because I go in thinking, “Please just have it today.” The stock is usually good, though every now and then a few cards are missing. Not a huge deal, but it does happen sometimes.

I was kind of in a hurry, but the payment went through fast and without any weird issues. Smooth overall.

I was expecting to wait a bit longer, but the payout came through faster than I thought. That definitely left a good impression and made the whole experience feel smooth.

The cards seemed to match the listed condition well. I’d say the description was accurate overall.

I ordered some cards and, they shipped a lot quicker than I was expecting. The package got here in just a few days, and there was no hassle or anything. So yeah, happy with the whole thing.

I had a quick question about my order and they got back to me faster than I expected. Nothing complicated, no back-and-forth hassle, just a simple helpful reply. If you’re waiting on info or unsure about something with your order, I’d say go ahead and reach out, they were easy to deal with.

My first impression sending a buylist order to Troll and Toad was a little nervous, because I had a bunch of cards going in and figured at least a few would get hit hard on condition.

Once they finished grading, though, it felt fair. The cards I had pegged as LP mostly came back as LP, and the few they downgraded made more sense after I went back and looked at my own photos again.

Payment wasn’t instant, but it didn’t take an unreasonable amount of time either. Overall, the experience was better than I expected from that first worried feeling, and I’d be comfortable using them again.

I ordered from trollandtoad.com and everything showed up just like I picked it. The cards were the right ones, the quantities were correct, and there weren’t really any issues. One card looked a little more worn than I expected, but it wasn’t a big deal. Overall, I’m happy with the order and would recommend giving them a try.

I ordered some cards and, the tracking was better than I expected. The shipping email showed up fast, and I could check where the package was most of the time, which is nice because you never know what’s really happening behind the curtain with these delivery networks.
It got here about when I figured it would, maybe a day later than I was secretly hoping. Not a big deal though. The updates were clear, nothing felt weird or overly mysterious, and the cards arrived fine, so I can’t complain too much...

I’ve placed a few preorders with Troll and Toad, they’ve been dependable for me. The shipping isn’t exactly lightning-fast right after release, because apparently patience is still a thing we’re expected to have, but everything did show up and was packed just fine. No major problems so far. I just wish the updates were a little better sometimes so I wasn’t left guessing like it’s some kind of mystery box experience...

The prices seemed fair to me, and I felt like I got good value overall. Happy with it

I found the cards I was looking for quickly, and checkout was simple enough. Still, I wish the whole process felt a little less like I had to click around and put in so much effort just to get it done.

I had to return a couple of cards because the condition wasn’t really what I expected. Support took about a few days to get back to me, but they did respond and issued the refund after I sent them back. Not perfect, but it was handled fairly, and I’d probably order again.

Got the cards and yeah, they’re real. No issues at all — appreciate it!

I had a small issue with my order, and support got it sorted out way quicker than I expected. I was just checking my email while finishing my coffee, and the fix came through before I even had to follow up. Painless experience

I ordered some cards from Troll and Toad and was impressed with how well they were packed. They came in a sturdy mailer, everything was secure, and none of the cards were bent or sliding around. I’m always a little nervous about corners getting dinged during shipping, but these arrived in great shape. Nothing fancy, just packed properly, which I appreciate. I’d definitely recommend them and would order again.